Critical thinking curriculum: curiosity, reasoning and decision-making from EYFS to Post-16

Helping young people question, weigh evidence and decide well

Young people face more information, opinion and persuasion than ever, much of it online. Our critical thinking curriculum, built into Life Lessons PSHE, helps them question what they see, spot bias and misinformation, and make safe, informed decisions.

Every Life Lessons PSHE lesson develops at least one of the 5 core skills, alongside RSHE and health education. Primary · Secondary · Post-16

Why it matters

Why critical thinking matters

Young people face more information, persuasion and AI-generated content than ever. Critical thinking keeps them safer online, improves learning in every subject and is the skill employers value most.

33%

spotted the ads

Only a third of 8 to 17 year olds who use search engines could identify the paid adverts at the top of Google results.

Source: Ofcom, 2025

23%

taught to spot fake news

Fewer than 1 in 4 children say they have ever been taught how to spot fake news.

Source: Ofcom, 2025

+8

months’ progress

Teaching metacognition, thinking about your own thinking, adds around 8 months’ progress, with similar impact from early years to secondary.

Source: Education Endowment Foundation

~70%

of employers

Nearly 70% of employers see analytical thinking as an essential core skill, the top skill in the WEF Future of Jobs Report 2025.

Source: WEF, via FM Magazine

Safer online and offline

Checking sources, spotting bias, misinformation and manipulation, and pausing before believing or sharing.

Better learning in every subject

Questioning, weighing evidence and reflecting on mistakes help pupils in English, maths, science, humanities and beyond.

Ready for work and life

Analytical thinking, problem-solving and good decisions are what employers, and adult life, demand.

Our framework

How we build critical thinking

Our framework draws on evidence of how curiosity, perspective-taking, evaluating information and problem-solving develop from early childhood to adulthood.

01

Inquisitive nature

Developing curiosity, asking deeper questions and exploring where other people’s ideas come from.

02

Connecting actions to outcomes

Linking words and behaviours to short and long-term consequences, and taking responsibility.

03

Confident expression

Putting thoughts, ideas and opinions clearly, even when they challenge the popular view.

04

Considering perspectives

Listening to opposing views, questioning our own starting points, and learning from disagreement.

05

Navigating uncertainty and evaluation

Analysing complex information, spotting bias and solving problems strategically.

The role of metacognition and reflection

Questioning starting points

Recognising our own misconceptions, blind spots and outside influences.

Iterative problem solving

Testing first solutions critically, adapting plans with new evidence, and managing setbacks.

The conditions pupils need

Motivation and engagement

Wanting to question and explore

  • A classroom culture that values thoughtful questions over quick answers
  • Stories and case studies build engagement without personal vulnerability
  • Changing your mind and learning from misconceptions are celebrated

Psychological safety

Feeling safe to disagree and be unsure

  • Trusted adults and clear norms for respectful debate
  • Wrong turns and uncertainty are treated as part of learning
  • Safe spaces to say ‘I don’t know yet’ without fear of judgement

Reasoning strategies

Tools to evaluate and decide

  • A toolkit for questioning sources, spotting bias and weighing evidence
  • Sentence starters, true or false reasoning and perspective-taking
  • Practised across subjects, so habits transfer to real-life dilemmas

What pupils learn

To be safe, joyful and healthy, I need to…

01

Develop curiosity and ask questions about the world

02

Confidently express thoughts, ideas and opinions

03

Make connections between actions, words and consequences

04

Question our starting point and reflect on past actions

05

Consider and stay open to multiple viewpoints

06

Accept and learn from views we disagree with

07

Evaluate and analyse complex information

08

Accept uncertainty without rushing to judgement

09

Practise strategic problem solving

How it builds

From curious explorers to independent thinkers

Young children explore and ask questions through play. Step by step, they learn to weigh evidence and perspectives, until by Post-16 they can spot bias, anticipate consequences and adapt their plans independently.

EYFSExploringCuriosity through play
  • Trying new things
  • Simple cause and effect
  • Offering own ideas
  • Noticing impact on others
KS1QuestioningAsking and listening
  • Asking relevant questions
  • Knowing others think differently
  • Not everything is true
  • Disagreeing respectfully
KS2EvaluatingWeighing ideas
  • Deeper questions
  • Spotting misconceptions
  • Seeing several perspectives
  • Taking responsibility
KS3Checking the evidenceIs it true or genuine?
  • Looking for evidence
  • Outside influences on choices
  • Testing first solutions
  • Distanced scenarios and case studies
KS4 and 5Independent judgementReady for adult life
  • Spotting bias and logical flaws
  • Anticipating long-term impact
  • Challenging own understanding
  • Adapting plans under pressure
Adult-ledIndependent

Progression

The full progression, stage by stage

Pupils develop critical thinking in their Life Lessons PSHE lessons, across 4 strands. Progress is spiral, not linear: it can fluctuate with confidence, context and social pressure, and pupils revisit each strand as they grow.

EYFS

Ages 3 to 5

  • Curiosity and questioning: Actively explores new ideas and objects, and has a go at something new.
  • Actions and consequences: Acknowledges when their actions affect someone they care about, and takes responsibility with support.
  • Perspectives and disagreement: Offers their own ideas during discussion, rather than repeating earlier answers.
  • Evaluating information and problem solving: Shows early curiosity in play, and begins to test simple cause and effect.

Key Stage 1

Years 1 and 2

  • Curiosity and questioning: Asks relevant questions, and tells people clearly what they’re thinking.
  • Actions and consequences: Notices when they have an unintended impact on someone around them.
  • Perspectives and disagreement: Understands others think differently, and disagrees respectfully.
  • Evaluating information and problem solving: Links several ideas together, and accepts we can’t know everything or believe everything is true.

Key Stage 2

Years 3 to 6

  • Curiosity and questioning: Asks questions that deepen understanding, and adjusts explanations for the audience.
  • Actions and consequences: Takes active responsibility for actions, including harm, and reflects on how to avoid it in future.
  • Perspectives and disagreement: Appreciates nuance and different perspectives, and sees disagreement as a chance to grow.
  • Evaluating information and problem solving: Critically evaluates information, spots misconceptions, and carries on healthily when unsure.

Key Stage 3

Years 7 to 9

  • Curiosity and questioning: Explores how we know if something is true or genuine, and looks for supporting evidence.
  • Actions and consequences: Connects behaviour with impact, and recognises how outside factors influence choices.
  • Perspectives and disagreement: Accepts people hold different views that change over time, and discusses them actively.
  • Evaluating information and problem solving: Critiques first solutions, looks for alternative routes, and sees opportunity in not having all the answers.

Key Stages 4 and 5

Years 10 to 12

  • Curiosity and questioning: Seeks diverse information, spots blind spots, and challenges their own understanding.
  • Actions and consequences: Anticipates the short and long-term impact of decisions, and acts accordingly.
  • Perspectives and disagreement: Manages conflict sensitively, and engages with differing social views and their root causes.
  • Evaluating information and problem solving: Spots bias and flaws in logic, evaluates options, and adapts plans under pressure.

Practice makes progress

How pupils practise and apply the skill

We can practise critical thinking like any other skill, through a continuous cycle.

1Curiosity and questioning
2Guided practice and dialogue
3Evaluation and application
4Reflection and iteration

Explicit teaching

Direct exploration of questioning, true or false reasoning, spotting bias and decision-making.

Knowledge that grounds decisions

Relevant, understandable facts give young people a solid base for good decisions.

Concrete depiction and scaffolding

Visuals of behaviour and consequences, plus sentence starters to support reasoned responses.

Distanced scenarios and case studies

Stories, videos and ambiguous scenarios come before pupils challenge personal beliefs.

Practice across subjects

Analysing sources in humanities, testing hypotheses in science and critiquing texts in English.

Termly observation

Staff observe tangible behaviours each term using the Skills Metric, across lessons, tutor time and social dilemmas.

Want to see how this works in your school?

Critical thinking: your questions answered

What is critical thinking?

Critical thinking is evaluating and analysing complex information, spotting bias or flaws in logic, and connecting our actions, words and consequences. At Life Lessons, it goes hand in hand with curiosity and open-mindedness.

What is a critical thinking curriculum?

A critical thinking curriculum explicitly teaches young people to question, weigh evidence, consider other views and make reasoned decisions, building those skills step by step as they get older. Ours is taught through the Life Lessons PSHE curriculum from EYFS to Post-16.

How does critical thinking keep young people safe online?

It helps them check sources, recognise adverts, misinformation and manipulation, and pause before they believe or share something. Ofcom’s 2025 research found only around a third of 8 to 17 year olds could spot the paid adverts in Google results.

How does critical thinking help in other subjects?

The same habits, such as asking good questions, weighing evidence, considering other views and learning from mistakes, help pupils analyse sources in history, test hypotheses in science and critique texts in English. Teaching metacognition, which sits at the heart of critical thinking, adds around 8 months of progress over a year, from early years to secondary (Education Endowment Foundation).

Why is critical thinking important for employability?

Employers consistently rank analytical thinking among the most important skills. In the World Economic Forum’s Future of Jobs Report 2025, nearly 70% of employers saw it as an essential core skill. As AI and technology change jobs, the ability to evaluate information, solve problems and adapt will matter even more.

Is it a separate programme?

No. It’s built into the Life Lessons PSHE curriculum, so you don’t need to find extra time in the timetable. Our weekly In the News lessons also give pupils regular practice with real current affairs.

How do you measure progress?

Critical thinking is one of 5 core skills we track. Staff observe tangible behaviours each term using our Skills Metric. Find out more about impact tracking.

Build critical thinking across your school

Tell us about your school and we’ll show you how the Life Lessons PSHE curriculum builds critical thinking from EYFS to Post-16. No obligation.